Jump to content
THE BROWNS BOARD

Can This Draft Start like our 1978 Draft?


Flugel

Recommended Posts

Folks, I know I get scarier than the Exorcist and Stephen King when I start talking QBs so I'm going to contemplate a little learning from our history here. I want defense with 3 of our first 4 picks so let me set the scene before you hurry to tell me my thinking cap is cutting off all the oxygen to my brain.

 

We will be getting Des Bryant back with fresh legs to the D-line who's even played on the Nose at times to showcase how flexible he is for any of the techniques Williams will want him to line up in. In addition, I have a feeling Williams can tap Nate Orchard similar to the way he looked when he finally got a chance to play more at the end of 2015. I see these 2 guys as gravy to what we will add in the draft.

 

Okay, so the best first round in Cleveland during my lifetime tuning in as a fan was Ozzie Newsome and Clay Matthews way back in 1978 when I was only 14 years old. One guy was a WR at Alabama that Bear Bryant hailed as the best WR he ever coached prior to his NFL position change. The other guy was a LBer from USC that was talented enough to play any of the 4 LBer spots we had here in Cleveland. Both guys played for at least 14 years at a high level combining may Pro Bowls. One became a Hall of Fame player and deservedly so. In the process, they became key leaders by example on both sides of the ball as our 80s teams participated in more playoffs games than any other decade after the 60s. That's what getting 2 picks right in round 1 right in Cleveland can lead to.

 

2017 Round 1: Okay, so we can kick this draft off going defense 1st overall with the pick of the litter. I'm leaning toward Jonathan Allen or Reuben Foster while the mock draft consensus will most likely favor Myles Garrett after he aces the jumps and 40 time in Indy. Mayock already told us yesterday during the Senior Bowl while some of his highlights were airing that we have to take this guy. Don't overthink it. Okay. He's spent way more time on Garrett and others than me so I'll trust his studies.

 

And now for a guy I don't want us to gift wrap to Pittsburgh or Baltimore in a league where productive TEs have proven to be invaluable to QBs like Peyton Manning (Dallas Clark), Tom Brady (Gronk & Bennett), Drew Brees/Russell Wilson (Jimmy Graham), Philip Rivers/Drew Brees (Antonio Gates), Phil Simms (Mark Bavaro), Troy Aikman (Jay Novacek), John Elway (Shannon Sharpe), Drew Bledsoe (Ben Coates) and Trent Dilfer/Joe Flaccoseagulls (Shannon Sharpe), Cam Newton (Greg Olsen), Joe Montana/Steve Young (Brent Jones), Tony Romo/Dak Prescott (Jason Witten). This draft has another guy that appears to be destined for a great NFL career as a TE from the Alabama football program with a Head Coaching legend (Nick Saban). He's a much bigger target than Ozzie with great wheels and good hands. His name is O.J. Howard and I do not want him playing for anyone else in our division. You want to help a struggling QB? A target like this can really do so fast.

 

After these 2 guys, we can go right back to defense in round 2 to make 3 of our first 4 picks on that side of the ball. Then we can kick off round 3 with a Center like Pocic or whatever BPA falls on our door step.

 

This could be very similar to our round 1 in 1978 not only by adding a TE from Alabama in particular; but also by adding the best Defensive player available on our door step. He might even be a LBer for all we know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 91
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I don't follow saying our young QBs need a TE to throw to. They already have one. What we really need pretty badly though is a blocking TE, preferably one who can also catch. If OJ is that, then great, but I'm not taking him for catching ability alone. Just my .02.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't follow saying our young QBs need a TE to throw to. They already have one. What we really need pretty badly though is a blocking TE, preferably one who can also catch. If OJ is that, then great, but I'm not taking him for catching ability alone. Just my .02.

 

No problem War. I appreciate your point of view. I just have a feeling there's a bunch of FOs knowing that a true Freshman QB didn't even come close to tapping Howard's skill set like some NFL offenses can. If memory serves me right, Greg Olsen didn't have big Sexy stats at the U before he became a 1st round draft pick that made multiple Pro Bowls. In fact, he only scored 6 TDs in 3 years (2 of those seasons he only scored once) while never exceeding 40 rec with 489 yards as his personal best.

 

I feel like Barnidge's performance wasn't just slipping because our our QBs - he looked like he lost some quickness and dropped a lot of catchable passes (out of character). He went from 79 rec for 1043 rec yards 65.2 ypg and 9 TDs in 2015 down to 55 rec 611 rec yards 35.2 ypg and 2 TDs in 2016. The yards per catch also decreased by about 2 yards as well. He wasn't that good of a blocker either, which all caught me off guard following the only Pro Bowl season of his career. He will be 32 in September so I don't get the sense he has a lot left; but I could certainly be wrong about such a hunch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't follow saying our young QBs need a TE to throw to. They already have one. What we really need pretty badly though is a blocking TE, preferably one who can also catch. If OJ is that, then great, but I'm not taking him for catching ability alone. Just my .02.

My attitude is if you want a blocker, but in another tackle or guard.

 

Ozzie wasn't a good blocker. Then again, who cared? I am starting to think we have to take Howard if he is there at 12. What's wrong with putting a pro-bowl player on your roster?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gotta love Barnidge, but he was drafted in 08, and has gotten clobbered at times.

If he is out of the lineup due to injury, the Browns offense is toast. Howard would

lengthen Barnidge's career. He fits the Browns' profile exactly as far as being

qualified on all criteria. It's a serious, interesting thought. Not a desperate need...

but I can see it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i remember Z & I having a conversation in the Tavern during a preseason game at GB last season. Not only the Kwan Williams benching himself was a strange ordeal. But we were questioning. Why was Nate Orchard still out there playing with 3rd & 4th's on depth chart kids late in game? Orch was not a Sashi pick, but a red flag went up saying things may not have been going well in Nate's evaluation either before injury? Feeling Better with a Gregg Williams in the house :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Jim Brown wasn't just a bad blocker, he was lazy at it, he downright refused to do it. Perhaps Cleveland fucked up drafting him?

No doubt they did. LOL.

 

I have said for years that if you have a play maker, screw the blocking factor. That is pretty much like saying you can't draft Joe Thomas because he can't run or catch the ball.

 

I am happy as hell he have Joe Thomas. I don't care if he can catch or run. We drafted him to block.

 

I know you don't totally value that, but it is necessary. The point being that if you are looking for a back or te, fuck the blocking

factor. Let the blockers you signed do that. Let the runners and receivers be judged on how well they run and catch.

 

This isn't hard. Only a Mongolian Idiot might do worse than we have, and that person has a legit excuse.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

JB could block, when he wanted to...

 

I am happy as hell he have Joe Thomas. I don't care if he can catch or run. We drafted him to block.

 

Got me curious so I checked and it does not appear that Joe has a single TD... be it by fumble recovery or OT eligible.

 

That seems wrong. He needs at least one before he hangs it up.

 

The winning SB TD in his last game would be a nice parting gift.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is DeValve supposed to be a TE or WR for us?

 

We're bad.

We need the biggest, fastest and/or strongest guy available when it's our turn to pick. Even if it's a LT....cos he can play RT until it's his turn at LT.

 

That's how Chuck Noll turned around the steelers after he took over. After he was hired he gathered the players and told them that he watched their film and knew why the steelers kept losing...and that it was because of them (the players). He said, Ya can't run fast or jump high, you're not shifty or powerful, and quite frankly I'm going to have to replace a whole lot of you.

 

That's pretty much where we're at. Whoever is the biggest, fastest sumbitch available when it's our turn to pick MOST probably fits a need for us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

JB could block, when he wanted to...

 

Got me curious so I checked and it does not appear that Joe has a single TD... be it by fumble recovery or OT eligible.

 

That seems wrong. He needs at least one before he hangs it up.

 

The winning SB TD in his last game would be a nice parting gift.

 

Aw, Ghoolie is going to hate this but I'm easily entertained. Watched the Pro Bowl, and with 10 out of 10 Joe is in pretty exclusive company. ESPN heaped some praise on him. Hey Tom, you can cut the crap now- every one of the 10\10 club is in the HOF. Thomas can't help it if the rest of the team sucks.

 

"Just four other players in NFL history — Merlin Olsen, Mel Renfro, Barry Sanders and Lawrence Taylor — were named to the Pro Bowl in at least the first 10 seasons of their careers. All of those players are Hall of Famers; only Olsen, with 14, went over 10."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Aw, Ghoolie is going to hate this but I'm easily entertained. Watched the Pro Bowl, and with 10 out of 10 Joe is in pretty exclusive company. ESPN heaped some praise on him. Hey Tom, you can cut the crap now- every one of the 10\10 club is in the HOF. Thomas can't help it if the rest of the team sucks.

 

"Just four other players in NFL history — Merlin Olsen, Mel Renfro, Barry Sanders and Lawrence Taylor — were named to the Pro Bowl in at least the first 10 seasons of their careers. All of those players are Hall of Famers; only Olsen, with 14, went over 10."

 

When you say Tom - I'm guessing you mean Ghoolie. I've always been a huge Joe Thomas fan.

 

One of these days people will figure out Ghoolie isn't here to talk football (ie; wasting time trying to convince him a 10 time Pro Bowl player doesn't suck).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

When you say Tom - I'm guessing you mean Ghoolie. I've always been a huge Joe Thomas fan.

 

One of these days people will figure out Ghoolie isn't here to talk football (ie; wasting time trying to convince him a 10 time Pro Bowl player doesn't suck).

 

Of course I meant the other Tom. :) Joe is probably a lock first ballot HOFer when he hangs 'em up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

O.J. Howard always seems to save his best work for the post season. Here's his first matchup with Clemson as a junior the night he became a National Champion. A couple TDs and some nice seal blocks (like the one on Henry's first TD run). He had well over 100 yards receiving in that game. Barnidge will be 32 this year; and I think this kid will be a great target at 6'6". He also played well in the Senior Bowl. There's a lot of room for improvement especially in staying with his blocks longer but I think this guy has the frame to be a dual purpose TE like a Jason Witten with better gears. I'd hate to see Baltimore or Pittsburgh draft him. The last time we drafted a guy in round 1 to play TE here from Alabama - we frequented post seasons throughout his Hall of Fame career. We could do a lot worse - and have repeatedly.

 

http://draftbreakdow...s-clemson-2015/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Barn is a decent receiving TE with a knack for finding holes in a zone and above average hands. But he is a liability as a blocker and has issues vs. competent man coverage.

 

What troubles me more is his YAC... or lack of it. I looked before this season's start at his YAC and it was not good. I grade in can't remember him doing anything this year to improve that.

 

YAC is an area where I think Devalve can improve the TE position, but he's not a blocker either

 

I see OJH as a significant upgrade in those two areas, blocking and YAC, without diminishing the positive aspects of the position. In short, I see him as one of the best, most well-rounded TEs to enter the league in years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Barn is a decent receiving TE with a knack for finding holes in a zone and above average hands. But he is a liability as a blocker and has issues vs. competent man coverage.

 

What troubles me more is his YAC... or lack of it. I looked before this season's start at his YAC and it was not good. I grade in can't remember him doing anything this year to improve that.

 

YAC is an area where I think Devalve can improve the TE position, but he's not a blocker either

 

I see OJH as a significant upgrade in those two areas, blocking and YAC, without diminishing the positive aspects of the position. In short, I see him as one of the best, most well-rounded TEs to enter the league in years.

 

Well articulated! I was sort of surprised at how well Howard consistently hustled into position to be an effective blocker (seeing plenty of room for growth though). I hope people watch that whole highlight of the Clemson game I linked up in my previous post. He was the game changer in that passing game the last time Bama was crowned a National Champion. I'll guarantee a guy like Ozzie Newsome that played at Alabama will be all over this kid. I keep reminding myself that if you take this guy away from a true freshman QB and put him in an NFL offense that leans on a TE - he can be a significant.

 

As for Barnidge, he turns 32 in September and I posted the huge difference between his 2015 and 2016 stats (understanding part of that wasn't all his fault). When I watched some of his highlights, he almost looked like he was fighting some pain more than defenders. He looked like he was waddling side to side. I remembered hearing more about his blocking skills when he arrived than what he had done receiving so if those are diminishing too - the timing of an O.J.Howard couldn't be any better. It's not that I don't like DeValve. In fact, I think I'd prefer to see him in the slot in the near future. My concern with DeValve is he seems too injury prone to count on. I like his talent though...

 

This probably won't mean a thing to a lot of us outside of me; but after the Senior Bowl I saw 2 guys wearing a Cleveland Browns baseball cap on their domes. They were O.J. Howard and Davis Webb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To quote The Citadel: Winter is here.

 

Freedom of speech also means others have a freedom of listening or choosing not to. This is why there's a menu of topics to choose from right? I'll continue to understand the reason a message board exists for a passionate fan base like we have is because people want to talk about their favorite team year round. Since there's Bowl Games, All Star games and pre-draft workouts that will impact where players go in the draft all throughout Winter - I'm glad we have an ideal place we can discuss this.

 

To understand our journey ahead, me must first understand where we have been. This includes what has worked well every bit as much as what has not. For example, the TE position we drafted with a purpose to upgrade in 1978 became the foundation and focal point for my 2 favorite QBs (Sipe and Kosar) of my lifetime as a fan. Ozzie's ability as a college WR to transition as an NFL TE opened up opportunities for our WR Corps and our QBs to become very efficient. Playing gridiron chess when you can dictate/manipulate where you want the Safety via an attack piece Ozzie eases everything.

 

Lindy Infante preferred to stretch defenses horizontally from sideline to sideline, which would eventually allow Kosar some uncontested deep routes all the while Ozzie commanded attention in the seams. In essence, this wasn't a tough place to play QB at all. I'll even venture to say, Ozzie was a pretty good blocker in the 2nd and 3rd tiers of defenses; but he wasn't a huge help with trying to set the edge of the first tier. Howard looks like he can be good at helping to set the edge IMO...

 

New school fans that never saw our 80s teams frequenting post seasons - won't see the TE position value like those of us that witnessed it. I don't mean any disrespect in saying that. This thread shows me there's prolly a lot more young guys besides Bacon thinking what the flock is so earth shattering about a TE?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As for Barnidge... I remembered hearing more about his blocking skills when he arrived than what he had done receiving so if those are diminishing too...

 

Your memory is better than mine... I don't remember hearing anything about Bran's blocking when he arrived... good or bad.

 

I do remember that he sat behind Jim Dray, who was a good blocker at the time, but whose skill in that area went mysteriously south in his final season with us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Freedom of speech also means others have a freedom of listening or choosing not to. This is why there's a menu of topics to choose from right? I'll continue to understand the reason a message board exists for a passionate fan base like we have is because people want to talk about their favorite team year round. Since there's Bowl Games, All Star games and pre-draft workouts that will impact where players go in the draft all throughout Winter - I'm glad we have an ideal place we can discuss this.

 

To understand our journey ahead, me must first understand where we have been. This includes what has worked well every bit as much as what has not. For example, the TE position we drafted with a purpose to upgrade in 1978 became the foundation and focal point for my 2 favorite QBs (Sipe and Kosar) of my lifetime as a fan. Ozzie's ability as a college WR to transition as an NFL TE opened up opportunities for our WR Corps and our QBs to become very efficient. Playing gridiron chess when you can dictate/manipulate where you want the Safety via an attack piece Ozzie eases everything.

 

Lindy Infante preferred to stretch defenses horizontally from sideline to sideline, which would eventually allow Kosar some uncontested deep routes all the while Ozzie commanded attention in the seams. In essence, this wasn't a tough place to play QB at all. I'll even venture to say, Ozzie was a pretty good blocker in the 2nd and 3rd tiers of defenses; but he wasn't a huge help with trying to set the edge of the first tier. Howard looks like he can be good at helping to set the edge IMO...

 

New school fans that never saw our 80s teams frequenting post seasons - won't see the TE position value like those of us that witnessed it. I don't mean any disrespect in saying that. This thread shows me there's prolly a lot more young guys besides Bacon thinking what the flock is so earth shattering about a TE?

You don't have to convince me. TEs are one of the most important weapons on any NFL team these days. I would only add that I think the Browns have pretty good one in Barnidge. He can be called a "Pro Bowl" TE. And a really good second one would be nice as well. DeValve may in fact become that.

If I questioned the TE position (I don't think I did) it was only to say that I think this team has much bigger holes to fill.

But, yea, a good TE can be a QBs best friend.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You don't have to convince me. TEs are one of the most important weapons on any NFL team these days. I would only add that I think the Browns have pretty good one in Barnidge. He can be called a "Pro Bowl" TE. And a really good second one would be nice as well. DeValve may in fact become that.

If I questioned the TE position (I don't think I did) it was only to say that I think this team has much bigger holes to fill.

But, yea, a good TE can be a QBs best friend.

 

Some good points - thanks Gips! The only thing I'll disagree with is where Barnidge is at now vrs where he was in 2015 when he made the Pro Bowl. Here's what I typed earlier in this thread:

 

I feel like Barnidge's performance wasn't just slipping because our our QBs - he looked like he lost some quickness and dropped a lot of catchable passes (out of character). He went from 79 rec for 1043 rec yards 65.2 ypg and 9 TDs in 2015 down to 55 rec 611 rec yards 35.2 ypg and 2 TDs in 2016. The yards per catch also decreased by about 2 yards as well. He wasn't that good of a blocker either, which all caught me off guard following the only Pro Bowl season of his career. He will be 32 in September so I don't get the sense he has a lot left; but I could certainly be wrong about such a hunch.

 

From the title I carefully selected, it would remind me a lot of our 1978 if the pick of the litter on defense can team up with the next talented target (OJ Howard) we draft out of Alabama to play TE here. This one is 6'6" tall with a nice catch radius and some raw but intriguing blocking skills that can be refined. I put a link of his game vrs Clemson from 2 years ago somewhere in this thread to show you how lethal he can be in the passing game, while he also had some nice blocks (ie; the one on one outside where he got great position inside to seal off the Clemson DE for a long TD run by Henry). He seems more dual purpose than he'll probably get credited for while the Clemson game highlight will display his X-factor to a downfield passing game. Not only am I intrigued by his talent; but I'm also worried Ozzie Newsome remembers how important Shannon Sharpe was in preventing Dilfer from killing Dilfer. If we don't draft OJ Howard, just be prepared to watch him helping Baltimore or Pittsburgh.

 

If the pick of the litter on D can give us the consistency and productivity of a Clay Matthews toward whatever their specific role will be in tandem with what OJ Howard's dynamic can open up, could be the killer combo we've longed for in round 1 all this time. The draft is deeper in the secondary plus we get 2 defenders back from injury (Des Bryant and Nate Orchard), which should accimate well to Williams' schemes/alignments.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...